Property Abroad
Blog
Prime Insurance has avoided a $60 million fine in a Georgia liposuction death case.

Prime Insurance has avoided a $60 million fine in a Georgia liposuction death case.

Prime Insurance has avoided a $60 million fine in a Georgia liposuction death case.

The U.S. Supreme Court has upheld a federal appeals court ruling that Prime Insurance Co. is not liable for $60 million in damages following the deaths of two patients who survived liposuction at a Georgia clinic.

The judges ruled that the insurance payout was limited to $100,000 under the clinic's professional liability policy. Most of that amount had already been spent on attorney's fees.

In addition, the judges concluded that the four-year statute of limitations applied because part of the claim alleged a breach of jury duty on the part of Prime. The six-year statute of limitations for breach of contract did not apply in this case.

The court did not allow a claim for violation of Georgia's premium refund laws because only the insurance commissioner, not individuals, has that right.

In their ruling, the judges noted that the decision will be considered fresh air for insurance companies as many of them have been exposed to liability for exceeding policy limits for years in various courts.

In this case, Opulence Aesthetic Medicine Clinic in Kennesaw, Georgia, purchased a professional liability policy with a limit of $50,000 per claim and $100,000 total. The premium was $3,992.

In 2013, Dr. Nedra Dodds performed liposuction surgery on April Jenkins, who died the same day.

Recommended real estate
Buy in Georgia for 25437€

Sale flat in Batumi 27 467 $

1 Bedroom

1 Bathroom

46 м²

Buy in Georgia for 29361€

Sale flat in Batumi 31 705 $

1 Bedroom

1 Bathroom

58 м²

Buy in Georgia for 97297€

Sale flat in Batumi 105 065 $

2 Bedrooms

1 Bathroom

61 м²

Buy in Georgia for 70182€

Sale flat in Batumi 75 785 $

1 Bedroom

1 Bathroom

45 м²

Buy in Georgia for 46286€

Sale flat in Batumi 49 981 $

1 Bedroom

1 Bathroom

44 м²

Buy in Georgia for 88958€

Sale flat in Batumi 96 060 $

2 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

79 м²

A few months later, Dodds performed a similar procedure on Erica Beaubourg, who died a few hours after surgery. These incidents were widely reported on local news. Police investigated, but criminal charges against Dodds were later dropped. The doctor filed for bankruptcy in 2017.

The Jenkins and Beaubourg families sued the clinic and won $60 million each. However, Prime's insurance company pointed out that the attorneys' fees ate up the bulk of the available coverage. The court ultimately found that the clinic's insurance coverage had been exhausted by the defense in the lawsuits, and therefore Prime had no further liability to the plaintiffs.

This court decision is recognized as an important victory for insurance companies, as it will help avoid wrongful claims from injured victims.

Comment