Inside the numbers: the potential of Phuket real estate
One of the most common questions I've been asked lately is about the potential existence of a bubble in the real estate market in Phuket. While this is a popular term, many who ask this question do not understand what a bubble is. The most well-known case of a bubble in the real estate market in recent history occurred during the mortgage crisis in the United States in 2007. Bubbles have also occurred in other sectors, such as the dot-com crisis in 2000 and the crypto crash in 2018. A fundamental sign of a bubble is the achievement of unreal valuations and a deviation from the basic fundamental principles of sustainable growth. This usually leads to a crash, and in the case of real estate, it would mean a sharp decline in property prices.
In many parts of the world, especially in the West, the real estate market is prone to bubble formation due to liquidity influences. When cash is absent, loans or mortgages become increasingly creditworthy, and the risk escalates until a collapse occurs. And then the scenario of a crash unfolds. The foundations of the real estate market in Phuket are very clearly defined and differ from any other market I know. They can be best summarized as follows - most real estate transactions are conducted in cash. The overall market value of resort-level properties significantly exceeds the prices of homes domestically. Thai buyers who finance or take out loans for properties represent a minority of the market segment. Project development is often linked to phasing and actual sales, so the rate of developer defaults remains low. The geographical distribution of buyers on the island spans multiple countries, economic indicators, and currencies, which effectively mitigates risk for any single market.
However, there are signs that Phuket is reaching the peak of the real estate cycle, and we can learn lessons from past events. More than ten years ago, the island saw an influx of small, affordable condominiums developed by builders from Bangkok. With Asia being one of the first regions in the world to emerge from the financial crisis and a growing middle class, it was evident that Thai buyers viewed this segment as their own class of investment. Similar to Bangkok, at that time this segment was referred to as "Mickey Mouse apartments," which were small and inexpensive. Payment terms were focused on completion, and buyers often purchased multiple units with the intention of selling them on demand, before the transfer (final payment or mortgage initiation). To avoid overwhelming you, this speculative phase eventually began to decline, as Phuket simply lacked end consumers for such a volume of products, and the rate of buyer defaults often reached 30-40 percent or more of the total inventory. Ultimately, many Thai developers refocused on Bangkok, and over time the inventory was absorbed. Now we are witnessing a surge in two distinct segments - condominiums and villas. As for condominiums, the profile of buyers here has a key distinction, although there is a sharp increase in the number of foreign buyers of these products. They are the most capitalized and capable of closing deals, so it is unlikely that the default rate will mirror what it was ten years ago.
As for villas and resort-level homes, the pandemic has led to a mass migration to Phuket, driven by urban exodus, changes in remote work, and an increasing focus on quality of life. This, combined with the radically changing geopolitical crisis in Eastern Europe, has suddenly made the island's retirement or secondary home sector a target for many end users. Global migration has changed our world, and Phuket's geographical location as a winter getaway for much of the Western world is a strong driver of demand. The Thai government's approved programs, including the long-term visa program "Thailand Elite," the retirement program, and the education guardianship visa that extends to families, are key factors attracting real estate buyers. But let's return to buyers from Eastern Europe, who have become a leading force in Phuket's real estate market over the past two years. This includes not only Russians but also investors from Ukraine, Kazakhstan, and Uzbekistan. In tourism, we always say that you can't stop if you can't get there, but this also applies to real estate buyers. Anyone who has visited Phuket International Airport during peak season sees that airlines from Eastern Europe outnumber any other carriers. As for Russians in particular, the increase in real estate transactions in Phuket is linked to the increasingly restrictive environment in the West regarding the banking industry, investments, and any kind of business. Due to financial instability within the country, despite the currency's depreciation, they view Thailand, and specifically Phuket, as a safe haven. Suddenly, real estate becomes the new bank for Russians.
It's hard not to notice the significant growth of the real estate sector in Phuket, which calls into question tourism as a key economic indicator. In the Greater Bangtao area alone, which includes Cherngtalay, Laguna, and Layan, over 20,000 residential units are either under development or in the planning stages. However, when it comes to purchases and investments, these individuals and groups have high liquidity, primarily make cash payments, and adopt a long-term strategy regarding premium properties. I don't even want to attempt to predict global geopolitical events, but it's unlikely that we will see a wide range of turbulence in the next 3-5 years, so in most cases, buyers' money remains invested in real estate. With minimal exposure to lending or a retreat of buyers back to their home countries, any kind of crash is unlikely to occur. From past events, we have learned that there is a tide and ebb, similar to the ocean's tide, and real estate is a cyclical endeavor. Once a peak is reached, there is froth, and niche opportunities arise. For resort properties, low-price sales are usually due to death, divorce, or personal financial issues, so broad market movements are likely to be less probable. What happens, as before, is that demand levels off, the upward sector of the secondary market emerges, and supply becomes competitive with new developments or primary sales. This may be a reasonable outlook for the low season of 2024. But, in my opinion, on the broader scale of global upheavals, Phuket's position as a safe haven for real estate investment may avoid the cycle. Growth in other sources of geographic migration, the return of China, and other geopolitical events will undoubtedly encourage more diversity among buyers and migrants to Phuket. As for the bubble, I leave that to the reader's judgment.
Comment
Popular Posts
Popular Offers
Subscribe to the newsletter from Hatamatata.ru!
Subscribe to the newsletter from Hatamatata.ru!
I agree to the processing of personal data and confidentiality rules of Hatamatata