He Retired in Montepulciano — How Italy Cut His Healthcare and Housing Bills
Why one American chose real estate Italy for retirement
When Brad Allan and his wife moved from Austin to Montepulciano, they were chasing something practical as much as romantic: lower living costs and easier travel. For readers interested in the property market and real estate Italy, Allan’s story is useful because it ties specific cost comparisons and practical choices to a real outcome — a full move in 2023 to Southern Tuscany on the Umbria border.
In the first 100 words we must say this plainly: real estate Italy can mean lower ongoing household costs for some Americans, especially those who face large private healthcare bills at home. Allan’s case is not universal, but it is instructive: he is 60, retired from running a furniture chain, bought a house in Southern Tuscany after years of travel, and now publishes advice on his YouTube channel, BradsWorld.
The headline numbers: healthcare and taxes that changed the math
Allan framed his move in cold financial terms. He compared what he was paying or facing in the US to what he now pays in Italy, and the results drove his decision.
- He paid €2,800 (about $3,228) as a one-year buy-in to Italy’s national healthcare system once they became residents.
- A private MRI with and without contrast cost him €200.
- An X-ray cost $30.
- A general practitioner visit cost €50 and a specialist visit €120.
- He says he saved about $20,000 a year in property tax compared to what he paid in Texas, and over $20,000 a year in healthcare costs.
- He estimates paying an extra $5,000 in federal tax after moving, but that still left him ahead in total annual costs.
Those are concrete, itemised data points you can use as a baseline when comparing your own projected US costs to a move to Italy. If you are under Medicare age, as Allan was at 60, the difference in out-of-pocket health spending can be decisive.
How healthcare made the move affordable
Allan’s main financial argument rests on healthcare. In the US, private health insurance premiums and out-of-pocket costs can exceed several thousand dollars a month for someone retired and not yet eligible for Medicare. He says a single month’s US insurance payment could cover their entire year of buy-in in Italy.
A few practical takeaways from his experience:
- The buy-in fee can be affordable: Allan paid €2,800 for the year. For many expats, that single number will be the first hard comparison to monthly US premiums.
- Public-access vs private clinics: He used a private MRI clinic for €200 and paid small fees for routine imaging and doctor visits. Even when paying outside the public system, the unit costs were far lower than typical US charges.
- Waiting times and expedited services: Allan notes you can pay for expedited services and private clinics when you need speed; the baseline costs still remain modest.
From an investor or buyer perspective, healthcare expenses are an operating cost of living that should be included in any long-term budget alongside property taxes, utilities, maintenance, and travel costs.
Property, taxes and the hidden savings from moving to Italy
Allan contrasts what he calls “property tax” in Texas with his new cost structure in Italy. He believes his prior US property tax bill of about $20,000 a year was a major drain. Even if income taxes in Italy are higher on some bands, his combined savings on property taxes and health costs more than offset any added income tax.
What this means for prospective buyers and investors:
- When evaluating a purchase in Italy, calculate both the one-time and recurring taxes you will face in your home jurisdiction and in Italy.
- Property tax regimes are local: Italy’s municipal property taxes and fees differ by location and how the property is used (primary residence vs rental). Allan’s experience indicates total recurring housing-related costs can be lower than comparable US bills, but that depends on the US location you compare against.
- If you have taxable assets or passive income in the US, speak to a cross-border tax accountant. Allan noted a small increase in federal tax (about $5,000) after moving, which you must weigh against other savings.
Lifestyle gains that factor into the investment case
Allan’s move wasn’t only about numbers. He emphasises lifestyle and travel convenience as part of his decision calculus.
- Montepulciano is a tourist town with a slower pace; he says people are friendly and conversation about work is uncommon, a cultural shift he appreciates.
- Dining out is competitively priced: Allan reported that a night out in town with a good bottle of wine often costs about $60 per couple in a tourist area.
- Europe as a travel base: Allan uses Italy as a hub. Low-cost flights and a well-connected rail network let him and his wife take spontaneous trips across the continent — to places like Tenerife, the French Alps, Scotland and London — at far lower incremental cost and effort than transatlantic travel from the US.
For buyers who imagine property Italy only as a speculative purchase, think instead about the non-financial returns: quality of life, ease of intra-Europe travel, and cultural change. Those matter for many retirees and can justify higher acquisition prices in sought-after towns.
How Allan bought and settled: practical steps and tips
From Allan’s recollection, several practical elements stand out for Americans looking to buy property and relocate to Italy:
- Start with extended reconnaissance trips. Allan and his wife spent six weeks touring Italy in 2019 before committing.
Practical checklist for buyers and investors:
- Get a clear estimate of your US ongoing housing, tax, and health costs to compare with the Italian costs you will face.
- Consult a cross-border tax adviser before you change residency; understand reporting requirements and treaty implications.
- Plan for practicalities: pet transport, local driving and registration, banking and currency exchange, and the cost of property maintenance.
- Use local agents and attorneys for purchase contracts and notary fees — Italian property transfers involve different actors and timelines than in the US.
Risks and downsides Allan acknowledges (and we underline)
Allan’s story is persuasive but it is not risk-free. I will point out a few caveats that any buyer should take seriously.
- Currency risk: Your income or savings in dollars can fluctuate in value when exchanged into euros. A weaker dollar raises the cost of living, a stronger dollar lowers it.
- Local bureaucracy: Residency, tax registration, and property transfers in Italy take time and paperwork. Expect administrative friction.
- Market liquidity and resale: Some rural Italian properties can be slow to sell. If you buy in a small town, your exit window may be longer than for urban properties.
- Healthcare nuance: Allan paid to enter the national system and used private clinics. Depending on your health needs and residency status, your costs and access could differ.
- Lifestyle tradeoffs: The slower pace, later meal times and lower expectation of small talk are positive for some, less attractive for others.
What this means for investors and second-home buyers
If you are buying property Italy as an investment, Allan’s example highlights a different use case: buying a primary residence to reduce recurring living costs rather than pursuing short-term rental yields. For investors considering buy-to-let in Tuscany or nearby regions, reflect on these points:
- Rental demand is seasonal in tourist towns; net rental yield will vary across the year.
- Buying as a primary residence can give tax advantages on certain municipal fees and can change how the property is taxed domestically.
- Long-term appreciation in desirable regions like Tuscany has been steady but local — you should treat each town and micro-market differently.
If your objective is long-term residency plus travel convenience, Montepulciano and southern Tuscany can be attractive because of air and rail connections and an established expat community.
Local lifestyle details that affect running costs
Small habits change cost-of-living calculus. Allan’s anecdotes point to several micro-cost advantages:
- Dining out can be inexpensive even in tourist towns — he reports a total bill for dinner and wine close to $60.
- Routine medical imaging and doctor visits have low unit costs: €200 for MRIs, €50 for GP visits.
- Short European flights or regional train trips unlock weekend travel opportunities at low incremental cost.
These micro-costs compound: lower per-service charges for healthcare, smaller restaurant bills, and cheaper short-haul travel add up to meaningful annual savings compared with many parts of the US.
How to evaluate whether a move like Allan’s works for you
Ask yourself the following questions and run the numbers before making any relocation decision:
- What are your current annual healthcare and property tax costs in the US? Are you under Medicare age?
- What will you pay in Italy for the services you use frequently (doctor visits, imaging, medication) and for the healthcare buy-in as a resident?
- How much will your federal tax bill change if you become an Italian tax resident? Get a cross-border tax projection.
- Do you want frequent intra-Europe travel, or do you prefer being closer to family in the US? What are the non-financial tradeoffs?
- Do you prefer a tourism-heavy market that may be pricier but more liquid, or a quieter town with lower prices but slower resale?
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How much did Allan pay to use Italy’s national healthcare?
A: Allan reported paying €2,800 for a one-year buy-in to the national healthcare system, about $3,228 at the time he quoted it.
Q: What are typical out-of-pocket healthcare costs in his experience?
A: Allan cited a private MRI for €200, an X-ray for $30, a general practitioner visit for €50, and a specialist visit for €120.
Q: Did he save on taxes after moving?
A: Allan says he paid about $5,000 more in federal taxes but saved approximately $20,000 in property tax and over $20,000 in healthcare costs, leaving him net ahead.
Q: Is Montepulciano a good investment location for property buyers?
A: Montepulciano is an established tourist town in Southern Tuscany with lifestyle and travel advantages. As with any purchase, evaluate local market liquidity, seasonal rental patterns, and your intended use (primary residence vs rental) before buying.
Closing assessment
Brad Allan’s move to Montepulciano is a practical example that for some Americans the math favors buying property Italy and relocating when healthcare premiums and property taxes at home are very high and frequent travel within Europe is a priority. His concrete figures — €2,800 for the healthcare buy-in, €200 for an MRI, and roughly $20,000 in annual savings on both property tax and healthcare — give a baseline you can use in your own calculations. If you are under Medicare age and face heavy health and property tax bills in the US, run a side-by-side comparison that includes buy-in costs, local taxes, and realistic maintenance and travel budgets before committing to a move.
Tags
We will find property in Italy for you
- 🔸 Reliable new buildings and ready-made apartments
- 🔸 Without commissions and intermediaries
- 🔸 Online display and remote transaction
International Real Estate Consultant
Subscribe to the newsletter from Hatamatata.com!
Subscribe to the newsletter from Hatamatata.com!
Popular Posts
We will find property in Italy for you
- 🔸 Reliable new buildings and ready-made apartments
- 🔸 Without commissions and intermediaries
- 🔸 Online display and remote transaction
International Real Estate Consultant
Subscribe to the newsletter from Hatamatata.com!
Subscribe to the newsletter from Hatamatata.com!
I agree to the processing of personal data and confidentiality rules of Hatamatata
Need advice on your situation?
Get a free consultation on purchasing real estate overseas. We’ll discuss your goals, suggest the best strategies and countries, and explain how to complete the purchase step by step. You’ll get clear answers to all your questions about buying, investing, and relocating abroad.
Irina Nikolaeva
Sales Director, HataMatata