Property Abroad
Blog
Lukashenko distributes prime Belarusian real estate to his Serbian allies - OCCRP

Lukashenko distributes prime Belarusian real estate to his Serbian allies - OCCRP

Minsk

Originally the winner of an architectural competition in Minsk in 2008, the plan for the futuristic project was a 300-meter-high skyscraper, glass towers twisted like corks, and a gondola canal to ride between the residential blocks. But today, the project is a high-rise residential building that looks like a brick fortress hiding in the Belarusian capital.

The journalists' analysis of the land registry data showed that Zomex Investment, Dana Astra and Belinte Robe (renamed Emirates Blue Sky) have at least 11 construction projects around Minsk. These three companies are the largest developers in the city and have been granted more than 400 hectares of land worth about $1''billion.

Hidden corporate maneuvering

In addition, detailed investigations by journalists revealed that the owner of these companies engaged in covert corporate maneuvering that allowed him to continue profiting from deals with Lukashenko's government while avoiding EU sanctions.

Till recently, all three companies were owned by Dana Holdings, registered in Cyprus and formerly owned by Nebojša Karic, a member of a wealthy and influential family from Serbia. In December 2020, the European Union blacklisted Dana Holdings for benefiting from Lukashenko's regime.

The Karic family anticipated the EU's moves: days before the sanctions were announced, Dana Holdings was replaced by a company from the United Arab Emirates''under the name Enterprise Developments Holding Limited. The director and owner of Enterprise Developments is Mostafa el Tobghi, according to the company's ownership documents. In 2013, an advertisement for Dana Holdings on the popular Belarusian news website TUT.by featured the name of Mostafa Al Tobghi as the executive director of Dana Holdings.

After replacing the owner of the companies, Karic was able to circumvent EU sanctions and continue to benefit from his ties to Lukashenko.

The growth of the construction industry in Belarus.

In the past decade, Belarus, encouraged by international institutions such as the World Bank, has sought to move away from the state-controlled economy established during the Soviet Union. However, instead of a market economy, a system of crony capitalism has emerged, from''which benefits well-connected private firms. Top officials or their proxies gain privileged access to entire sectors of the economy and withdraw capital from the country through offshore companies.

Construction has become one of the most profitable businesses in Belarus. In 2011, more than half of housing projects in Minsk were still controlled by state corporations.

Recommended real estate
Buy in Portugal for 295978£

Sale flat in Palmela 398 926,00 $

3 Bedrooms

2 Bathrooms

125 м²

Buy in Portugal for 1900000€

Sale house in Tavira 2 127 173,00 $

10 Bedrooms

10 Bathrooms

201 м²

Buy in Portugal for 1650000€

Sale house in San Nicola Archella 1 847 282,00 $

3 Bedrooms

3 Bathrooms

133 м²

Buy in Portugal for 5900000€

Sale villa in Arma di Taja 6 605 434,00 $

5 Bedrooms

5 Bathrooms

290 м²

Buy in Portugal for 4300000€

Sale villa in Albenga 4 814 130,00 $

12 Bedrooms

1800 м²

Buy in Spain for 5000000€

Sale villa in Oeirash 5 597 826,00 $

4 Bedrooms

5 Bathrooms

474 м²

By 2020, private companies were building 90 percent of new projects in the Belarusian capital. Most of the benefits of this boom are attributable to just three companies: Zomex Investment, Dana Astra and Belinte Robe.

Their owners, the Karic brothers, are reaping the fruits of their ties to Lukashenko, who has ruled Belarus since 1994 and is denied by the EU as the country's legitimate president.

Members of the Karich family''established ties to Lukashenko after their businesses became the subject of an investigation in Serbia in the mid-2000s. Prosecutors accused the Karicas of illegally enriching themselves in a privileged position under the rule of Slobodan Milosevic, but later dropped the charges.

In 2009, Nebojsa Karic's uncle, Dragomir Karic, invited Lukashenko to an economic forum in the Serbian ski resort of Kapaonik. A year later, Dragomir was appointed to lead the construction of a large complex in Minsk called Minsk City, and then Karic's company, Dana Astra, took over the project.

The president's sister-in-law, Lilia Lukashenko, was listed in company documents in 2017 as deputy director of Dana Astra, but a spokeswoman for the Karic family said she was no longer''working there. Dana Astra also received free advertising in state media, including television news programs that covered the apartment sale.

The Karic family's political connections in Belarus have proven to be very lucrative. Zomex Investment's net income for 2019 was more than $35 million and its profit margin was 61 percent, well above the industry average. For 2020, the profit margin was another 67.5 percent and profits totaled approximately $22 million. Under an agreement with the government, Zomex pays no income taxes.

Despite all the advantages it has as one of the regime's favorite developers, Zomex has been unable to meet its obligations. Minsk Lighthouse was no exception.

Comment